Cindy is truly the best of the best and an amazing agent! She helped my husband and I during the hectic home buying process over the course of 2 long years. She always had our best interest at heart when offering suggestions and was available to answer any and all questions whenever they came up. She is incredibly thorough, diligent, and proactive and pays attention to every necessary detail to ensure a smooth home buying process. She has even continued to help us with some follow-up details after closing without hesitation. We can't thank her enough for all of her support and would recommend her to everyone we know!

Cindy Mistretta is by far the best real estate professional we have ever encountered....and we have had lots of experience with realtors since our family relocated 9 times. Once our children finished high school, we decided to sell our Mendham home and listed through Cindy, who came highly recommended by a Sr VP at Coldwell Banker. She went above and beyond the call of duty. Cindy is professional, knowledgeable, thorough, detailed and just a lot of fun to work with. She is a terrific communicator and unlike a lot of folks these days, she actually likes to personally call and talk to people as opposed to always texting. She always made herself available ... and also made that either she or an associate was at our home for showings in case the potential buyer had questions. Cindy is all about the personal touch and makes you feel like you are her most important client. She was fabulous at staging the home as well, even going as far as to shop for home accessories on our behalf if we didn't have the time or energy. We highly highly recommend Cindy Mistretta as a real estate agent for buying or selling a home. One thing is for certain, she will always do what is in the best interest of her clients.

Mendham Seller

Cindy is very professional, knowledgeable, hardworking and very pleasant to work with. She was a dual agent in our transaction and helped us significantly every step of the way to bring us to closing day. We are in our dream home because of Cindy. She answered all our questions and was extremely patient throughout the entire process. I will definitely refer her in the future. Choose Cindy she’s the best!

Mendham Buyer

Cindy was fabulous. She gave great and reasonable advice in preparing our house for sale. She was so helpful in establishing negotiating positions in our sale. She assisted us also in looking for a new home- suggesting areas for us to look and having an opinion going in on resaleability. I couldn’t be more happy with our choice. She took our interests to heart and had our back.

Chester Seller

An absolutely incredible agent! Every recommendation and suggestion Cindy made was always in my best interest. She has hours all throughout the day and clearly devotes all of her resources to her real estate career. When I buy another house, Cindy will be the first I call!

Morristown Buyer

Highly recommend!! Cynthia is amazing!!!! I met her randomly at an open house and I immediately got good vibes. She always looked out for my best interest. Very knowledgeable, responsive, great at negotiating, didn’t let anything slip through the cracks. It was my first time buying a home and she helped me every step of the way. My final walk through was a bit chaotic with some new issues that popped up. She worked really hard to make sure I got everything that I needed fixed before closing.

Morristown Buyer

We have been working with Cindy Mistretta on selling our Mendham home for a few years. She is very professional, patient and responsive. One attribute that sets her apart is her willingness to recommend tactics, but to then step back and let you to make your own decisions. She does not try to hard sell you into doing things her way. This includes any price adjustments, lead generation tactics, etc. She is very knowledgeable about the selling process and diligently provides feedback of different prospective buyers comments, or even those of other agents. And, given her prior corporate background, she is very professional in her demeanor and advice. We would recommend her highly to anyone looking to sell, rent or buy in the Mendham/Chester/Morristown area, and consider her a friend.

Mendham Seller

We recently sold our house of many years with the assistance of Cindy Mistretta from Caldwell Banker. I can not say enough about the job she did in helping us. At our initial meeting she went through in detail the process of listing and selling a property. She clearly was very knowledgeable about the market and other recent sales and listings around us which helped us decide on a listing price. After a thorough inspection of the house Cindy made several suggestions to make our house the most attractive to potential buyers. Once the property was listed she quickly held open houses and got the word out to realtors in the area. Within two weeks we had an offer that we were very happy with. She then did everything she could to make the closing process as stress free as possible. This included getting the various inspectors into the house when we were not home, getting us in contact with reliable vendors to make needed repairs and taking necessary paperwork to town hall. Cindy guided us through the process and was always available by phone to answer any questions we had. The results speak for themselves. We could not have been happier with her services.

Mendham Seller

We first met Cindy at an open house in Mendham 8 years ago. She had such a nice way about her: eager to assist but not pushy at all. My husband and I were a bit reserved as we weren't quite sure what we were looking for and had never worked with a realtor before. However, there was something about Cindy that made us both feel instantly comfortable with her. A few days later, we received a simple email from her letting us know that if we needed any assistance, she would be happy to help. We ended up setting up an afternoon with her to see homes in Mendham that she thought might be of interest to us. We then proceeded to work with her for an entire year (because we are picky!!) looking for homes in Mendham, Chester, Bernardsville and Basking Ridge. She was so knowledgable, intelligent, positive and super fun to work with! We often changed our minds on what we were looking for, but she was wonderful, patient and she eagerly kept showing us houses and helped us narrow down what we really wanted in a home. She was extremely available to us over the course of an entire year and worked long hours to ensure that we were happy - also catering to my husband's work schedule. Long story short, we ended up buying a home in Mendham 7 years ago that she did an excellent job negotiating on! Not only did she find us the perfect house, but she became a great friend to our family and someone who I know I can always turn to if I have questions on homes/taxes/referrals/etc. We were so lucky to have met Cindy and we know we worked with the best realtor going! Since purchasing our home, we have referred her to family and friends who have both bought and sold homes with her. We can't say enough good things about Cindy! If you are looking to buy or sell a home in the Mendham area, you have got to work with Cindy Mistretta! She's the best!

Mendham Buyer

As far as Mendham goes, our home was on the very low end, yet that did not affect the level of service, professionalism and commitment that Cindy demonstrated to sell our house. From advising us on how to prepare the house when first putting it on the market to consistently driving potential buyers for showings/open houses, Cindy was completely focused on selling our home and maximizing the price. She did a fantastic job communicating with us, discussing sales strategies and following up with potential buyers. As anyone knows that has sold their house, it is a very stressful experience, yet because Cindy is so positive, pragmatic and knowledgable, all in all, she created a great selling experience for us right up to (and even after!) closing. We would highly recommend Cindy without reservation.

Mendham Seller

We have had the pleasure of working with Cindy on both the buying and selling side of real estate transactions. Cindy's attention to detail, care for her clients, marketing expertise, sharp eye for staging/design and very pleasant personality all make for a positive real estate experience. She really goes above and beyond in every aspect of her job. We will highly recommend Cindy, without reservation, to anyone in our area who is looking for the best realtor to make their move! You will not be disappointed!

We recently sold our house of many years with the assistance of Cindy Mistretta from Coldwell Banker. I can not say enough about the job she did in helping us. At our initial meeting she went through in detail the process of listing and selling a property. She clearly was very knowledgeable about the market and other recent sales and listings around us which helped us decide on a listing price. After a thorough inspection of the house Cindy made several suggestions to make our house the most attractive to potential buyers. Once the property was listed she quickly held open houses and got the word out to realtors in the area. Within two weeks we had an offer that we were very happy with. She then did everything she could to make the closing process as stress free as possible. This included getting the various inspectors into the house when we were not home, getting us in contact with reliable vendors to make needed repairs and taking necessary paperwork to town hall. Cindy guided us through the process and was always available by phone to answer any questions we had. The results speak for themselves. We could not have been happier with her services.